The game did what it set out to do. It set out to create a
Frogger game that had some kind of story and adds a few adventure, even RPG-like elements to the series. You see, Frogger goes to this town to find his grandfather and while he's there, stumbles on this machine that can give him special abilities. By finding upgrades to this machine, he gets more special abilities, like 'jump longer'. Only by talking with the townspeople can he upgrade his machine and get to new stages. The action stages consist of classic
Frogger gameplay, which is to dodge and run away from as many things as possible. Now this was great back in the days of Atari, but now its just boring.
The RPG elements add nothing to the game, but random fetch quests. These random quests range from 'go get this from that person' or 'go get that from this person' to 'talk to everyone and see what they are thinking, while I decode this message'. Needless to say, these elements also give you the ability to throw your Gameboy through a window.
The action stages are sometimes cleverly designed, and sometimes 'I want to burn my Gameboy in the fiery pits of hell' designed. Normally the game makes you wait until some mushroom or other obscure enemy moves out of the way for you to move. Now this is okay the first time it happens, but having almost an entire stage with those damn mushrooms is just annoying. Definitely not fun. There are also 'boss battles' in Frogger's Journey: The Forgotten Relic. These consist of you running or dodging from the bosses' attempts to squish you with various means. Again, not fun.
Another gameplay design that just really annoyed me was that Frogger couldn't swim. That's right folks, frogs cannot swim. In one stage, you must jump on lots of lily pads before they sink into the water. If you go into the water, you die. Now, I would not have a problem with this if it was acid, lava or something dangerous. But water? Since when do frogs not swim? Did I miss that in biology? I think we, as gamers, should come together to petition for a title change. I think we should call the game 'Toader'. That way, at least this piece of crap would make sense.